Now showing 1 - 4 of 4
  • Thumbnail Image
    Some of the metrics are blocked by your 
    Item type:Publication,
    Entering the age of hybrid futures: A comparative study of human and GPT-generated scenarios
    (Elsevier BV, 2025-11-05)
    The increased use of Large Language Models (LLMs) in scenario generation presents new opportunities and challenges for futures research. While scenario development has traditionally emphasized human creativity, judgment, and deliberation, generative AI models such as GPT-3, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 are now capable of producing seemingly plausible future narratives at scale. This study investigates how scenarios generated by three generations of GPT models compare to human-authored scenarios on Europe’s futures. Using a curated dataset of 1080 human-authored scenarios pre-ChatGPT, the models were fine-tuned and prompt-engineered to generate 3240 scenarios. A comparative analysis was conducted using quantitative measures (n-gram overlap, lexical diversity, topic modeling, sentiment analysis) and qualitative expert evaluation through a Delphi survey (N = 42). Results reveal substantive differences in thematic emphasis, linguistic features, and emotional tone between human and machine-generated outputs. Experts frequently misclassified the origin of scenarios, highlighting the increasingly blurred boundary between human and AI authorship. However, plausibility assessments showed a subtle bias against scenarios labeled as AI-generated, while AI-generated scenarios were thematically biased towards technology-centered topics. These findings raise important questions for the methodological integration of LLMs into scenario practices and suggest future directions for hybrid human–AI collaboration in futures research. This study contributes to the notion that scenario work increasingly relies on hybrid human–AI collaboration, requiring futures researchers to engage with technology-augmented methods in meaningful ways.
    Type:
    Journal:
    Volume:
    Scopus© Citations 3
  • Thumbnail Image
    Some of the metrics are blocked by your 
    Item type:Publication,
    Frictionless Futures, Invisible Conflicts: The Case for Scenario Methodology in Human-AI IS Research
    (2026-12-13)
    Information systems (IS) research has established AI as a delegation-capable organizational actor with normative consequences. Yet this body of work is methodologically present-bound: it explains how humans and AI coordinate in existing arrangements, not what competing arrangements are possible before design and governance decisions foreclose them. IS has opened epistemological space for researching not-yet-accessible phenomena, but without specifying a method. I argue that scenario methodology fills this gap: not as a management tool, but as a research method that structurally preserves contested stakeholder positions, unresolved normative conflicts, and structured uncertainty. I call this epistemic friction. A comparative corpus study of 4,320 human-authored and GPT-generated scenarios shows what is lost when friction disappears: high-certainty, low-contention, technology-centric futures. Strategically appealing. Analytically impoverished. This pattern illustrates precisely what IS research on human-AI coexistence cannot afford to reproduce.
    Type:
    Journal:
    Issue:
  • Thumbnail Image
    Some of the metrics are blocked by your 
    Item type:Publication,
    Conceptualizing Collaborative Agentic Information Systems through Shared Cooperative Activity
    Autonomous multi-agent systems introduce a new organizational re- ality: humans and multiple AI agents pursuing shared goals, negotiating roles, and adapting responsibilities in real time. Yet existing frameworks for human-AI collaboration remain largely anchored in dyadic settings. Drawing on Bratman’s Shared Cooperative Activity theory, a systematic literature review, and expert consultation, we derive three collaboration principles for Collaborative Agentic Information Systems: dynamic goal alignment, specifying how shared objectives are continuously adapted; mutual orchestration, addressing how roles and decision rights must be dynamically negotiated; and adaptive action and co-learning, spec- ifying how participants proactively support each other while preserving human oversight as agent autonomy increases. We illustrate these principles through a Model Context Protocol, suggesting how resource, tool, and sampling layers pro- vide architectural primitives for human-multi-agent collaboration. These principles address how delegation, accountability, and human oversight can be sustained as organizations transition from dyadic human-AI interaction to multi-agent collabo- ration.
    Type:
    Journal:
  • Thumbnail Image
    Some of the metrics are blocked by your 
    Item type:Publication,
    Orchestrating Scaffolding AI Agents: Design Principles for Mechanism-Specific Learner Support
    (Springer Nature Switzerland, 2026-05-31) ;
    AI agents are increasingly adopted in higher education, yet current systems handle requests uniformly, promoting cognitive offloading over sustained skill development. With the rise of orchestrated multi-agent systems, learning goals can be targeted by specialized AI agents that each address a distinct scaffolding mechanism: conceptual, procedural, strategic, or metacognitive. This study follows a Design Science Research approach to derive design requirements from 32 student interviews, iteratively refine a prototype with 22 IS experts, 6 educators, and 34 students, and computationally analyze scaffold effectiveness. We contribute three design principles: (1) multi-agent coordination through a lead orchestrator that delegates to mechanism-specific sub-agents, (2) adaptive learner profiling that enables cross-session scaffolding fading, and (3) continuous institutional knowledge integration grounding scaffolds in verified course materials. Our effectiveness analysis reveals that delivery order predicted learning behavior, positioning orchestration as a key design concern for AI-assisted educational systems.
    Type:
    Journal:
    Volume:
    Issue: