Bring in the experts? Citizen preferences for independent experts in political decision-making processes
Journal
European Journal of Political Research
ISSN
1475-6765
Type
journal article
Date Issued
2021-05-02
Author(s)
Abstract
Do citizens welcome the involvement of independent experts in politics? Theoretical and empirical work so far provides conflicting answers to this question. On the one hand, citizens may demand expert involvement in political decision-making processes in order to ensure efficient and effective governance solutions. On the other hand, citizens can be distrustful of experts and reject the unaccountable and non-transparent nature of expertbased governance. This note investigates citizen preferences for the involvement of experts in different stages of political processes and across 'hard' and 'easy' political issues. Results show that, in the absence of explicit output information, respondents prefer independent experts over national elected representatives in the policy design and implementation stages, across political issues. For the crucial stage of decision making, respondents show no difference in their evaluation of processes that delegate decisions to experts or to elected representatives, with the exception of environmental policy, where expert decision making is preferred. These findings are relevant for ongoing discussions on how to incorporate independent experts in political decision making in a way that citizens find legitimate and on how to address increased citizen dissatisfaction with the representative democratic functions performed by political parties, governments and politicians.
Keywords
experts
process preferences
technocratic governance
technocracy
policy preferences
Publisher
Wiley
Volume
61
Number
1
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
open.access
Name
European J Political Res - 2021 - BERTSOU - Bring in the experts Citizen preferences for independent experts in political.pdf
Size
572.75 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
2ce516da67eefbb724953f6c0218fdad